Independent fashion watchdog Remake assessed big clothes companies on their environmental, human rights and equitability practices.
At a factory in Zhejiang province on China’s eastern coast, two mounds of discarded cotton clothing and bed linens, loosely separated into dark and light colors, pile up on a workroom floor. Jacket sleeves, collars and brand labels protrude from the stacks as workers feed the garments into shredding machines.
It’s the first stage of a new life for the textiles, part of a recycling effort at the Wenzhou Tiancheng Textile Company, one of the largest cotton recycling plants in China.
Textile waste is an urgent global problem, with only 12 per cent recycled worldwide, according to the Ellen MacArthur Foundation. Even less – only 1 per cent – of castoff clothes are recycled into new garments; the majority is used for low value items like insulation or mattress stuffing.
Nowhere is the problem more pressing than in China, the world’s largest textile producer and consumer, where more than 26 million tons of clothes are thrown away every year year, according to government statistics. Most of it ends up in landfills.
And factories like this one are barely making a dent in a country whose clothing industry is dominated by fast fashion – cheap clothes made from unrecyclable synthetics, not cotton. Produced from petrochemicals that contribute to climate change, air and water pollution, synthetics account for 70 per cent of domestic clothing sales in China.
China’s footprint is worldwide: E-commerce juggernaut brands Shein and Temu make the country one of the world’s largest producers of cheap fashion, selling in more than 150 countries.
What is circular sustainability?
To achieve a game-changing impact, what fashion expert Shaway Yeh calls “circular sustainability” is needed among major Chinese clothing brands. This means waste is avoided entirely.
“You need to start it from recyclable fibres and then all these waste textiles will be put into use again,” she said.
But that is an elusive goal: Only about 20 per cent of China’s textiles are recycled, according to the Chinese government – and almost all of that is cotton.
Chinese cotton is not without a taint of its own, says Claudia Bennett of the nonprofit Human Rights Foundation. Much of it comes from forced labour in Xinjiang province by the country’s ethnic Uyghur minority.
“One-in-five cotton garments globally is linked to Uyghur forced labour,” Bennett says.
In May, the US blocked imports from 26 Chinese cotton traders and warehouses to avoid goods made with Uyghur forced labour. But because the supply chain is so sketchy, Uyghur cotton is used in garments produced in other countries that don’t bear the ‘made-in-China’ label, Bennett says.
“Many, many, many clothing brands are linked to Uyghur forced labour through the cotton,” she said. They “hide behind the lack of transparency in the supply chain.”
Temu scored zero on human rights
While China is a global leader in the production of electric cars and electric-powered public transport and has set a goal of achieving carbon neutrality by 2060, its efforts in promoting fashion sustainability and recycling textiles have taken a back seat.
According to a report this year from independent fashion watchdog Remake assessing major clothing companies on their environmental, human rights and equitability practices, there’s little accountability among the best-known brands.
ADVERTISEMENTThe group gave Shein, whose online marketplace groups about 6,000 Chinese clothing factories under its label, just 6 out of a possible 150 points. Temu scored zero.
Also getting zero were US label SKIMS, co-founded by Kim Kardashian, and low-price brand Fashion Nova. US retailer Everlane was the highest-scorer at 40 points, with only half of those for sustainability practices.
China’s domestic policy doesn’t help
Cotton recycled from used clothing is banned from being used to make new garments inside China. This rule was initially aimed at stamping out fly-by-night Chinese operations recycling dirty or otherwise contaminated material.
But now it means the huge spools of tightly woven rope-like cotton yarn produced at the Wenzhou Tiancheng factory from used clothing can only be sold for export, mostly to Europe.
ADVERTISEMENTMaking matters worse, many Chinese consumers are unwilling to buy used items anyway, something the Wenzhou factory sales director, Kowen Tang, attributes to increasing household incomes.
“They want to buy new clothes, the new stuff,” he says of the stigma associated with buying used.
The young Chinese entrepreneurs trying to make sustainable fashion cool
Still, among younger Chinese, a growing awareness of sustainability has contributed to the emergence of fledgling “remade” clothing businesses.
Thirty-year-old designer Da Bao founded Times Remake in 2019, a Shanghai-based brand that takes second-hand clothes and refashions them into new garments. At the company’s work room in Shanghai, tailors work with second-hand denims and sweatshirts, stitching them into funky new fashions.
ADVERTISEMENTThe venture, which began with Da Bao and his father-in-law posting their one-off designs online, now has a flagship store in Shanghai’s trendy Jing’an District that stocks their remade garments alongside vintage items, such as Levi’s and Carhartt jackets.
The designs are “a combination of the past style and current fashion aesthetic to create something unique,” Bao says.
Zhang Na has a fashion label, Reclothing Bank, that sells clothes, bags and other accessories made from materials such as plastic bottles, fishing nets and flour sacks.
The items’ labels have QR codes that show their composition, how they were made and the provenance of the materials. Zhang draws on well-established production methods, such as textile fibres made from pineapple leaf, a centuries-old tradition originating in the Philippines.
ADVERTISEMENT“We can basically develop thousands of new fabrics and new materials,” she says.
Reclothing Bank began in 2010 to give “new life to old things,” Zhang says of her shop in a historic Shanghai alley with a mix of Western and Chinese architecture. A large used clothes deposit box sits outside the entrance.
“Old items actually carry a lot of people’s memories and emotions,” she said.
A new market for vintage clothes
Zhang says she has seen sustainability consciousness grow since she opened her shop, with core customers in their 20s and 30s.
ADVERTISEMENTBao Yang, a college student who dropped by the store on a visit to Shanghai, said she was surprised at the feel of the clothes.
“I think it’s amazing, because when I first entered the door, I heard that many of the clothes were actually made of shells or corn (husks), but when I touched the clothes in detail, I had absolutely no idea that they would have this very comfortable feel,” she said.
Still, she concedes that buying sustainable clothing is a hard sell. “People of my age are more addicted to fast fashion, or they do not think about the sustainability of clothes,” she said.
Recycled garments sold at stores like Reclothing Bank have a much higher price tag than fast-fashion brands due to their costly production methods.
ADVERTISEMENTAnd therein lies the real problem, says Sheng Lu, professor of fashion and apparel studies at the University of Delaware.
“Studies repeatedly show consumers are not willing to pay higher for clothing made from recycled materials, and instead they actually expect a lower price because they see such clothing as made of second-hand stuff,” he says.
With higher costs in acquiring, sorting and processing used garments, he doesn’t see sustainable fashion succeeding on a wide scale in China, where clothes are so cheap to make.
“Companies do not have the financial incentive,” he said.
ADVERTISEMENTFor real change there needs to be “more clear signals from the very top,” he added, referring to government targets like the ones that propelled China’s EV industry.
Still, in China “government can be a friend to any sector,” Lu says, so if China’s communist leaders see economic potential, it could trigger a policy shift that drives new investment in sustainable fashion.
But for now, the plastic-wrapped cones of tightly-wound cotton being loaded onto trucks outside the Wenzhou Tiancheng factory were all headed to overseas markets, far from where their recycling journey began.
“Fast fashion definitely is not out of fashion” in China, Lu said.
ADVERTISEMENT